A study by researchers at Peking University’s Institute of Carbon Neutrality has unveiled how plants and animals respond differently to climate change in their seasonal biological cycles, or phenology. This large-scale analysis, led by Piao Shilong and Zhang Yao, highlights increasing mismatches between the two groups, raising concerns about the stability of ecosystems.

Published in Nature Ecology & Evolution, the study compiled an extensive dataset of phenological observations, including nearly half a million time series for plants (covering 1,629 species or genera across 248 events) and over 43,000 for animals, covering numerous species and events across four decades.

Global distribution of phenological records (s. climate change, plants, animals)
Global distribution of phenological records. a. Distribution of plant phenology observation sites; b. Distribution of animal phenology observation sites; c. Plant species; d. Plant phenology categories; e. Animal classes; f. Animal phenology categories. Credit: Lang et al. (2024) | DOI: 10.1038/s41559-024-02597-0 | Nature Ecology & Evolution

The findings show that plants exhibit a stronger response to warming, with later seasonal events such as fruiting advancing significantly over time. Nearly 30% of these changes were influenced by earlier events in the same growing season, suggesting that warming effects accumulate and amplify as seasons progress.

By contrast, animals displayed weaker and more variable phenological shifts. While insects showed slight advancements, the timing of seasonal activities in birds, mammals, and amphibians was often delayed. This variability stems from animals’ reliance on environmental cues, such as temperature or resource availability, which weakens the link between successive phenological events.

The research highlights that these divergent mechanisms may lead to increasing asynchrony between plants and animals. For instance, earlier flowering in plants might not align with the activity of pollinators, potentially disrupting trophic interactions. Such imbalances could ripple through ecosystems, affecting their overall functioning and stability.

The paper, co-authored by Lang Weiguang, Piao Shilong, and Zhang Yao, indicates the need to understand these phenological divergences to predict ecosystem responses to ongoing climate warming. The researchers emphasize that addressing such asynchrony is crucial to safeguarding ecological balance in a warming world.

Journal Reference:
Lang, W., Zhang, Y., Li, X. et al. ‘Phenological divergence between plants and animals under climate change’,Nature Ecology & Evolution (2024). DOI: 10.1038/s41559-024-02597-0

Article Source:
Press Release/Material by Peking University
Featured image credit: kuritafsheen77 | Freepik

Image: Aerial image of a kelp forest off the coast of California
Marine protected areas help kelp forests recover from marine heatwavesClimate

Marine protected areas help kelp forests recover from marine heatwaves

Marine Protected Areas can boost the recovery of globally important kelp forests following marine heatwaves, according to new research in Journal of Applied Ecology Summary:…
SourceSourceAugust 19, 2025 Full article
Image: Ocean under a cloudy sky, rain
Southern Ocean warming will bring lasting wet conditions to the western US and East AsiaClimate

Southern Ocean warming will bring lasting wet conditions to the western US and East Asia

Southern Ocean warming will mean a wetter West Coast Summary: As global temperatures rise, the Southern Ocean will gradually release heat it has absorbed over…
SourceSourceApril 3, 2025 Full article
Image
The mysterious X factor behind a year of unbelievable heatClimate

The mysterious X factor behind a year of unbelievable heat

By Kate Yoder & Sachi Kitajima Mulkey | Grist Predicting the future has always been a difficult, sometimes fruitless task, but scientists are surprisingly good…
SourceSourceJune 11, 2024 Full article